SA Rugby magazine SA Rugby magazine – Latest South African rugby news

South African rugby news, interviews, videos and more. Covering the Springboks, Bulls, Stormers, Sharks, Cheetahs and Lions, as well as schools and club rugby.

Primary Menu Search
SA Rugby magazine
  • Home
  • Springboks
  • Vodacom URC
  • Videos
  • Cars
    • Cheap cars for sale
    • Used Cars For Sale
    • New Cars For Sale
    • Demo Cars For Sale
  • Deals
    • One Day Deals
    • Nationwide Deals
      • Deals in Cape Town
      • Deals in Johannesburg
      • Deals in Durban
      • Deals in Pretoria
      • Deals in Port Elizabeth
    • Accommodation Deals
    • Romantic Getaways
    • Food and Drink Deals
    • Experiences
    • Health and Wellness Deals
You are here: Home ∼ Farrell’s tackle a penalty, say ex-referees

Farrell’s tackle a penalty, say ex-referees

Owen Farrell tackles André Esterhuizen Owen Farrell André Esterhuizen
Standard published on November 6, 2018

Former Test referees André Watson and Rob Debney say Owen Farrell’s tackle on André Esterhuizen should have been penalised.

In the 84th minute of last Saturday’s Test at Twickenham, Farrell appeared to shoulder charge Esterhuizen as the Boks searched for a match-winning try or penalty. The officials checked for foul play, but referee Angus Gardner ruled there was ‘enough of a wrap’ by Farrell’s arm on the far side to deem it legal and blew the final whistle.

On Sunday, World Rugby confirmed that the England skipper had not been cited as it had not reached the red-card threshold.

WATCH: Farrell’s tackle on Esterhuizen

In an interview with Netwerk24, Watson, who refereed 28 Tests between 1996 and 2004, said Farrell had used a ‘sharp shoulder’ to upend Esterhuizen and that ‘there’s no doubt that it was dangerous’.

He added: ‘It was not worthy of a red card and it was right that World Rugby did not cite the player, but there’s not much doubt that it should have been a penalty. There was no binding [with the shoulder] or even an attempt to bind.’

Former English referee Rob Debney agreed that the England flyhalf was lucky to get away with it.

‘Farrell’s tackle on André Esterhuizen was illegal and should have been a penalty. Just about every senior referee to whom I have spoken agrees with me,’ Debney wrote in The Times.

‘Angus Gardner, the referee, accepted that Farrell had made enough of an effort to wrap his left arm in the tackle. I disagree.

‘World Rugby says that an upright tackle with force is most dangerous and research shows that the tackler is most at risk. Yet the referee did not punish it. This must be sorted out or it will tarnish the Six Nations and the World Cup.’

Photo: Adrian Dennis/AFP Photo

Posted in News, Springboks, Test Rugby, Top headlines Tagged england, Owen Farrell, Springboks, Test Rugby, World Rugby

Post by SA Rugby magazine

← Previous Next →

Boks set for final tune-up against Georgia

The Springboks have ticked every box this month in their build-up to...

Rassie’s Boks of tricks is great for the game

Rassie Erasmus’ Springboks should be lauded for becoming world rugby’s great innovators,...

World Rugby deserves a rebel league

Rebel rugby is coming, and for players it's the deal Test rugby...

Razor’s edgy All Blacks must get real

The All Blacks, once comfortable in their own skin, now seem to...

Dupont the greatest? Hold your GOATs!

Antoine Dupont will finish his career as one of the game's most...

Ode to World Cup final

The ball was in play for 38 minutes in the 2023 Rugby...

Please Boks, never change

The world champion Springboks have to evolve their personnel, but not their...

Mr. Rugby on the Modern Game

Thanks to the wonders of artificial intelligence, we can now go beyond...

Rassie ref hom in die rooi

Rassie Erasmus is hardly the embarrassment that some are making him out...

Boks need to make mentality adjustment

The Springboks need to lose their underdog mentality, writes SIMNIKIWE XABANISA in...

Kolbe’s worth every penny

Cheslin Kolbe’s big-money move to Toulon should be welcomed as a massive...

Top six: Best and worst foreign imports

SARugbymag.co.za identifies six of the best and worst foreign players to play...

VIEW MORE
  • LIVE: Samoa vs Scotland
  • RECAP: Junior Boks vs Los Pumitas
  • LIVE: Springboks vs Italy
  • LIVE: AUNZ XV vs British & Irish Lions
    Haashim Pead 29 June 2025 Timothy Rogers Getty Images
  • Watch: There’s no substitute for Spead

  • Contact us
  • Terms and conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Competitions
  • Videos
  • Player Features
  • Joburg Etc
  • African Insider News
  • Rugby Championship
  • Super Rugby
  • Currie Cup
  • Varsity Cup
  • Gold Cup
  • Schools
  • Schools
  • SA Cup
  • Six Nations
  • Champions Cup
  • World Cup
  • Challenge Cup
Contact Us on WhatsApp

Connect with us on WhatsApp

CAPE TOWN OFFICE: 36 Old Mill Road, Ndabeni, Maitland, 7405, Western Cape > Telephone: (021) 530 3300 > Fax: (021) 530 3333
©Copyright 2025 SA Rugby magazine

Primary Menu

  • Home
  • Springboks
  • Vodacom URC
  • Videos
  • Cars
    • Cheap cars for sale
    • Used Cars For Sale
    • New Cars For Sale
    • Demo Cars For Sale
  • Deals
    • One Day Deals
    • Nationwide Deals
      • Deals in Cape Town
      • Deals in Johannesburg
      • Deals in Durban
      • Deals in Pretoria
      • Deals in Port Elizabeth
    • Accommodation Deals
    • Romantic Getaways
    • Food and Drink Deals
    • Experiences
    • Health and Wellness Deals

×