SA Rugbymag

South African rugby news, fixtures, results, video, interviews, and more. Covering the Springboks, Bulls, Stormers/Western Province, Sharks, Cheetahs, Kings and Lions, as well as schools and club rugby.

Primary Menu Search
  • Home
  • Super Rugby
  • Springboks
    • Fixtures and Logs
  • British & Irish Lions
  • Videos
  • Opinion
    • Nick Mallett
    • Jon Cardinelli
    • Craig Lewis
    • Dylan Jack
    • Simnikiwe Xabanisa
    • Mariette Adams
    • Omar Mouneimne
    • James Dalton
    • Stefan Terblanche
    • Jean de Villiers
    • Superbru
  • Tournaments
    • Rugby Championship
    • Currie Cup
    • European Champions Cup
    • English Premiership
    • French Top 14
    • Super Rugby
    • Pro14
    • Varsity Cup
    • Test Rugby
    • Six Nations
    • Sevens
    • Rugby Challenge
    • U20 Championship
    • Gold Cup
    • World Cup
    • Women’s World Cup
    • Lions Tour
    • Olympic Games
  • More
    • Fixtures & Results
      • Super Rugby
      • World Rugby Sevens Series
        • Fixtures
        • Log
      • European Champions Cup
        • Fixtures
        • Results
        • Log
      • English Premiership
        • Fixtures
        • Results
        • Log
      • French Top 14
        • Fixtures
        • Results
        • Log
    • Logs
    • Schools
    • Features
    • Teams
      • Kings
      • Bulls
      • Lions
      • Sharks
      • Stormers
    • Terms and conditions
  • COVID-19 Portal
  • You are here: Home ∼ Former ref: Garces got Louw penalty wrong

    Former ref: Garces got Louw penalty wrong

    Francois Louw wins a crucial breakdown turnover Francois Louw wins a crucial breakdown turnover
    Published on October 28, 2019

    Former Test referee Rob Debney believes that Wales should have been awarded a late penalty by Jerome Garces that might have given them a 19-16 lead in Sunday’s semi-final.

    The Boks eventually won by that three-point margin to set up a rematch of the 2007 World Cup final against Eddie Jones’ England.

    In his column for The Times, Debney was critical of Garces for ‘changing the way he refereed in the final 10 minutes’, which resulted in the Boks claiming the tense win and advancing to Saturday’s decider.

    ‘He penalised Wales with 10 minutes to go,’ wrote Debney. ‘They were on the 10m line and generating some good momentum and he incorrectly penalised Alun Wyn Jones for holding on.

    ‘Garces should have penalised South Africa as Franco Mostert did not move away and prevented Elliot Dee from clearing out Francois Louw. Wales should have had a kickable penalty that would have put them 19-16 up.’

    Replacement loose forward Louw again proved his considerable worth with the defining turnover to relieve some pressure for his side. The turnover allowed the Boks to advance upfield and eventually take the lead via the boot of Handre Pollard.

    ‘Just a few minutes later, he penalised Wales either for coming in from the side at a maul or collapsing it, but he had been letting this sort of thing go all game, added Debney. ‘Why give it at that stage of the game?

    ‘He changed the way he refereed in the final 10 minutes and contributed to South Africa winning it, which is not what a referee should do.’

    Full story

    Photo: The Times

    Posted in News, Springboks, Test Rugby, Top headlines, Tournaments, World Cup Tagged 2019 Rugby World Cup, Alun Wyn Jones, Franco Mostert, Francois Louw, Handre Pollard, jerome garces, referee, Rob Debney, semi-final, Springboks, Wales

    Post by SA Rugby magazine

    SA Rugby magazine




    ← Previous Next →

    Bulls vs Lions: Clashes to watch

    DYLAN JACK looks at five personal duels which could be decisive in the...

    Finding solutions to rugby’s ‘dead time’

    From scrum resets to TMO checks, drinks breaks and injuries – rugby...

    Goosen, Hougaard to boost Bulls

    Johan Goosen and Francois Hougaard’s impending moves to the Vodacom Bulls will...

    Saffas Abroad: Hall, Grobler star for resurgent Stade

    SARugbymag.co.za looks back at the South African players who featured for their...

    Terblanche’s fond farewell

    It’s been an honour to serve as CEO of the South African...

    Northern exposure should be welcomed

    Playing in the northern hemisphere will provide benefits on and off the...

    Column: All shapes and sizes

    It’s time to stop judging a player such as Frans Malherbe by...

    Column: When context is needed

    As highlighted by the Argentina controversy, ‘cancel culture’ needs a spoonful of...

    Dark cloud hangs over WP Rugby

    The problems at Western Province Rugby are layered, and everyone involved needs...

    From the mag: Foreign Favourites

    As Vodacom Super Rugby turned 25 this year, JON CARDINELLI picks an...

    Bulls rookies to watch

    After a massive exodus of players the Vodacom Bulls will be eager...

    Analysis: The new suffocate-and-strangle game

    For the Boks to emerge as World Cup winners, they need to...

    VIEW MORE


    COVID-19 Corona Virus
    South African Resource Portal

    ABOUT

    • Contact us
    • Competitions
    • Videos
    • Player Features
    • Subscribe
    • Terms and conditions

    TOURNAMENTS

      • Rugby Championship
      • Super Rugby
      • Currie Cup
      • Varsity Cup
      • Gold Cup
      • Schools
      • Six Nations
      • Champions Cup
      • World Cup

    OPINION

    • Mallett on SuperSport
    • Cardinelli column
    • Lewis column
    • Xabanisa column
    • Borchardt column
    • Superbru

    Primary Menu

    • Home
    • Super Rugby
    • Springboks
      • Fixtures and Logs
    • British & Irish Lions
    • Videos
    • Opinion
      • Nick Mallett
      • Jon Cardinelli
      • Craig Lewis
      • Dylan Jack
      • Simnikiwe Xabanisa
      • Mariette Adams
      • Omar Mouneimne
      • James Dalton
      • Stefan Terblanche
      • Jean de Villiers
      • Superbru
    • Tournaments
      • Rugby Championship
      • Currie Cup
      • European Champions Cup
      • English Premiership
      • French Top 14
      • Super Rugby
      • Pro14
      • Varsity Cup
      • Test Rugby
      • Six Nations
      • Sevens
      • Rugby Challenge
      • U20 Championship
      • Gold Cup
      • World Cup
      • Women’s World Cup
      • Lions Tour
      • Olympic Games
    • More
      • Fixtures & Results
        • Super Rugby
        • World Rugby Sevens Series
          • Fixtures
          • Log
        • European Champions Cup
          • Fixtures
          • Results
          • Log
        • English Premiership
          • Fixtures
          • Results
          • Log
        • French Top 14
          • Fixtures
          • Results
          • Log
      • Logs
      • Schools
      • Features
      • Teams
        • Kings
        • Bulls
        • Lions
        • Sharks
        • Stormers
      • Terms and conditions
    • COVID-19 Portal



    Subscribe
    ×